We asked our customers to rank the flavors. Tens of thousands of orders later, the results are in. Here's how Simply Beef Jerky's 9 flavors stack up ranked by reorder rate and review volume.
#1 Korean BBQ
The surprise champion. Korean BBQ leads all flavors in total reviews and has the highest reorder rate in the lineup. The Gochujang-inspired heat, sesame, and soy profile hits a sweet spot that keeps customers coming back. Bold, slightly spicy, and deeply savory it's the flavor that converts skeptics. If you've never tried it, this is where to start.
#2 Sweet & Spicy
Sweet & Spicy is the most gifted flavor in the lineup customers consistently buy it as a gift before it becomes their own personal favorite. Honey sweetness up front, slow-building heat behind it. The kind of combination that makes you reach for another piece before you've finished the last one.
#3 Bourbon Whiskey
For the flavor with the most passionate fan base, it's Bourbon Whiskey. Rich bourbon notes, natural hickory smoke, subtle sweetness. It earns some of the most enthusiastic reviews in the entire lineup the kind where customers describe eating the whole bag in one sitting.
#4 Classic Original
The benchmark. Classic Original is what beef jerky is supposed to taste like bold, smoky, deeply savory. It's the flavor we test all others against, and it consistently earns a 4.9-star rating. If you're new to Simply Beef Jerky, Classic Original tells you everything about the quality of the base product.
#5 Filet Mignon Original
The only flavor to average a 5.0-star rating. When you start with filet mignon one of the most tender and prized cuts of beef even the most skeptical jerky fans are converted. The result is softer, richer, and genuinely unlike any other jerky on the market. At $13.99/bag, it's premium by design.
#6 Garlic & Brown Sugar
Garlic & Brown Sugar consistently surprises first-timers. Roasted garlic and caramelized brown sugar create a sweet-savory combination that's deeply addictive. It's the flavor customers describe as "impossible to put down."
The Full Lineup
Rounding out the lineup: Teriyaki (the crowd-pleaser with a sweet glaze), Black Pepper & Sea Salt (clean and boldly seasoned), and Filet Mignon Teriyaki (premium filet mignon meets a rich teriyaki glaze). Every flavor is made with whole muscle beef, no artificial nitrates, and no MSG added.
Not sure which to start with? Take the Flavor Quiz on the homepage 4 questions, personalized result.
